Quote:
Originally Posted by
rectifried
➡️
...
There's no accounting for taste in art and especially music which hits people differently even on the same day and same person depending on how they feel.
Music is truly magic to humans.
However, homogenized versions of it is pretty much what's going on
Do you want to kick drum like your favorite artist? download it.
In the end, mechanized, disco and hip-hop that started a half century ago has won the battle at least in modern American music.
...
Thanks for this interesting post.
Musical homogenization isn’t something new or strange. In fact, it has always been part of human history. It helps define the style of a period, a culture, or a civilization. In Baroque Europe, for example, music followed similar rules: the same kinds of instruments, similar scales, and common ways of composing. The same thing happens in Hindustani music in India, where traditions are carefully passed down, and even in tribal societies, where music keeps community identity alive through repeated rhythms, scales, and sounds.
What makes our time different is something new: we can now access music and sounds from anywhere in the world, and from any period in history, instantly and for free. A while ago, I got lost browsing traditional instruments on Thomann and looked them up on YouTube. I found sounds I had never heard before, from places I barely knew existed. This is an incredible opportunity.
Of course, even today, the music industry has its own rules and trends, just like the courts of the Renaissance or ancient traditions. There is always a mix of popular taste, artistic research, and even some form of cultural influence or propaganda.
Yes, there is musical homogenization today. But maybe the real challenge of our time is something else: fragmentation. Music today is so diverse and spread out that it’s hard to find a shared direction. Everyone listens to something different, often alone, and it’s rare to find a group of people united by the same sound or style.
Could this be the real change, not that everything sounds the same, but that there’s no longer a strong, common voice that brings us together?